Peter Shally/Shirley
b. ca1750's. Lived in Washington Co. Maryland and Augusta Co. Virginia 

 

    < Back to the USA Lineage Index Page
 

Editor: This lineage needs updating - Last Update October 2022 (DNA result added under son Balsar)
Peter Shally/Shirley
born 29 September 1741, christened 3 January 1742 at Quitopahilla Lutheran Church at North Annville Township, Lancaster Co PA, son of Charles Schalley (likely the correct person);  He is recorded as a miller in Washington Co. MD 20 December 1785; After his removal to Augusta Co. Virginia, he was ordered to repay 28 pounds he had borrowed in Washington Co. MD plus 5 pounds in damages. Peter then acted as surety to the marriage of his daughter in Augusta Co VA in 1796; In 1799 Peter Shirley bought land in Madison Co. KY and was living there by 1800. Peter was living in Jessamine Co KY by 1806 and Harrison Co IN by 1813.

Quitopahilla (Hill) Lutheran Church, North Annville Twp., PA. Joh. Peter of Charles Schalley, b. Sep 29, 1741; bapt. Jan 3, 1742. Spon: Joh. Peter Kucher and wife Barbara.

1797 Augusta County VA March Court - Shelly vs. Rankin.....I, Peter Shelly, of Washington County, Maryland, to Frederick Rods, of same County and State, 20th December, 1785.

1797 Augusta Co. VA court file #458 - a suit was brought against Peter Shirley by John Canote Jr., (brother of Roseanna, wife of Christian Shirley), about the ownership of a bay mare. The depositions in the suit show some of the members of Peters family. Christian Shirley, lately married to a daughter of John Canote, Sr., son, Balser, daughter, Mary (of age). Also deposing was a Sally Argenbright and a Henry Harmon (of age), who were living at Peter's house, (file #458). In a report of this suit in Chalkley Volume #1 page 412, it is said that Sally, Henry and Christian are about to remove to Kentucky. The final judgement in the suit was in favor of Peter Shirley. NOTE: George Argenbright who married Ann Baer, sister-in-law of Valentine Shirley, (branch #29), had a daughter named Sally Argenbright.

1799 Augusta County VA May Court - John Canote vs. Peter Shally.--Mary Shally, only daughter of Peter Shally, deposes, that about a year ago, her brother Christian, who had some time before been married to a daughter of John Canote, Sr., sister to plaintiff. 24th November, 1797. Mary Shally (Shirley) and Henry Harmon are about to remove, and also Sally Argenbright, November 17, 1797. 4th September, 1797, Christian Shally is about to remove to Kentucky.

1799 March 4 Madison Co KY Indenture between Alexander Reid and his wife Rebekah of Madison County Kentucky of the one part and Peter Shurley of the County and state aforesaid of the other part witnesseth that the said Alexander Reid for and in consideration of the sum of two hundred and fifty pounds current money to him in hand paid by the said Peter Shurly ........etc. doth confirm unto the said Peter Shurly.......... seventy five acres lying and being in the County of Madison on the water of Taylor Fork of a branch of Silver Creek near Madison Courthouse and bounded as followeth. Beginning at the Sycamore trees standing on the bank of Taylor fork in a line of John Harts ....

1801 May 5 Madison Co DB E pg 173 Peter Shurley of Madison Co KY to Jonathon Shurley of Augusta Co VA; L250, 74 acres Taylor's Fork a branch of Silver Creek near the town of Milford bounded by creek, line of John Hart; <s> Peter Shelly (sic, then Shally in the clerk recording)

1802 November 16 Madison County Court of Common Pleas Case File #533 Commonwealth vs Shirley, Sheriff ordered to take Peter Shirley, Christian Shirley, Balser Shirley, George Shirley into custody $9.96 1/2 cents imposed on them in matter of Commonwealth vs Samuel West

1802 Madison County KY Circuit Court Case File #2741 Peter Shirley sued Charles Shirley for tresspass

1806, 1809 Jessamine Co KY Tax List - Peter Shirley

married ______________

Known children:

1(i). Christian Shirley born Feb 12, 1773 Washington Co. MD.  He died Dec 12, 1858 Floyd Co. IN. and is buried on the Woods farm near Edwardsville, IN. He came to Madison Co. KY where he bought land Aug 1799 from William and Mary McGuire. Mary was the daughter of Michael Shirley, (branch # 30).   By 1810 he had moved to Harrison Co. IN, a portion that later became Floyd Co. IN.  and he lived there until his death.

married Roseanna Canote Nov 28, 1796. She was born July 27, 1776 MD and died Jan 9, 1861 Floyd Co. IN.  Her parents were John Canote born May 12, 1725 Hagerstown and Rosannah born 1730 Hagerstown, Maryland. (NOTE: The Canote family also was in Madison Co.KY when Peter and Christian Shirley were there).

1(ii). Jonathon Shirley born Oct 4, 1774 MD, drowned fording the Wabash River in Vigo Co. IN April 24, 1862. In 1801 he bought land in Madison Co. KY from his father.  It appears he only lived there a short time as he soon sold the land to James and Frances (Shirley) Runkle. In 1841 he served as administrator to his father's property. He can be found in the 1850 census of Augusta Co. VA where  he is listed as a farmer 74 years of age, born in Maryland.   

married 1) Nancy Reif on April 8, 1801 daughter of John Reif of Augusta Co. VA,

married 2) Esther Swope; she was born 1778 died 1854.

1(iii). Frances Shirley She married James Runkle May 26, 1796 Augusta Co. VA (See Runkle family pedigree in the More Info link at the top of this page)

1(iv). Balser Shirley born about 1780 (age 1780-90 in 1830 and 1840 census). He moved to Madison Co KY with his father and relatives about 1800, He appears in the Grainger Co TN census in 1810, 1820 (tax), 1830 and 1840.

1802-04 Madison County KY Circuit Court Case File #2740 Patrick Shirley by his atty vs Wm McGuire (suit about a horse. Balser Shirley took the horse and put it into the hands of George Shirley) Witnesses subpoened including Christian Shirley. Includes a note penned by Peter Shally referring to Charles Shally about dropping other lawsuit

1830 Grainger TN Census - Balser Shirley 0110001000000-2000010000000 (age 40-50, b 1780-90)

1840 Grainger TN Census - Balser Shirley 0000200100000-0110001000000 (age 50-60, b 1780-90)

married 1) Catherine Peters on 26 April 1808 at Augusta Co. VA.

married 2) Magdaline Kerns on 1 February 1814 at Knox Co. Tennessee.

married 3) (possibly) Mary Magadelina Childress on 7 April 1842 in Knox Co TN

children: what is the source for these children?

2(i). Mary Magdaline Shirley born about 1801 Grainger Co. TN, age 49 in the 1850 Grainger Co TN census, enumerated in the Henry Carnes household (age 69); She never married birth age does not fit parent's marriage date. Source for this child?

2(ii). Rachel Shirley born about 1810 Grainger Co. TN; She married ______ Morgan

2(iii). John C. Shirley born 1815-20 Grainger Co. TN, age 10-15 in father's 1830 census household, age 20-30 in father's 1840 census household

2(iv). Patrick Allen Sherley born 10 May 1820 Grainger Co. TN, age 5-10 in father's 1830 census household, age 20-30 in father's 1840 census household; Enumerated in Grainger Co TN in 1850 census, age 30; also in 1870 census, age 50 and in the 1880 census, age 60; He died 27 March 1897. 

Patrick Allen Shirley, Tabitha Shirley and their granddaughter Mary

married Tabitha E. Curl  on 18 March 1840 in Grainger Co TN; She was age 28 in the 1850 census

children:

3(i). George Allen Shirley born about 1842 TN, age 8 in 1850 census; Married and enumerated in Grainger Co TN in 1870, age 26, enumerated in Grainger Co TN in 1880 census, age 37 (born Indiana)

married Sarah L. Livingston on 1 November 1866 in Grainger Co TN

children:

4(i). Tabitha Elizabeth Shirley born 2 February 1868 Grainger Co TN, age 3 in 1870 census, age 11 in 1880 census; She died 3 August 1897

4(ii). William Henry Shirley born 12 March 1869 Grainger Co TN, age 10 in 1880 census (as Wm A), He died 12 March 1912

4(iii). James Edward Shirley born 28 February 1871 Grainger Co TN, age 9 in 1880 census; He died 22 May 1942

4(iv). Arthur Allen Shirley born 25 June 1873 Grainger Co TN, age 7 in 1880 census; He died 5 August 1932

4(v). Kline Shirley born 15 March 1875 Grainger Co TN, age 5 in 1880 census; He died 21 November 1946

4(vi). John Fletcher Shirley born 7 September 1878 Grainger Co TN, age 2 in 1880 census; He died 8 September 1937

Ancestor of DNA Participant Kit #983902

4(vii). Mary Elizabeth Shirley born 7 September 1878 Grainger Co TN, age 2 in 1880 census

4(viii). Nancy Leanah Shirley born 14 July 1882 Grainger Co TN; She died 7 June 1883, died young

3(ii). Cordelia Virginia Shirley born 5 June 1845 TN, age 5 in 1850 census; She married Prior F. Ellis on 21 November 1861 in Grainger Co TN; She died in 1932

3(iii). Margaret E. (Mary) Shirley born 5 March 1851 TN; She died 1861, age about 10

3(iv). Malissa Francis Shirley born 13 October 1852 TN

2(v). Balser Shirley, Jr. doesn't fit father's 1830 or 1840 census houseold does he really exist, is the following marriage for the father instead?

married Mary Magadelina Childress on 7 April 1842 in Knox Co TN

2(vi). female Shirley born about 1825-30, age 0-5 in father's 1830 census household

Possibly Harriet Rebecca Shirley who married George Morgan on 12 October 1848 in Grainger Co TN

2(vii). female Shirley born about 1825-30, age 0-5 in father's 1830 census household

1(v). Mary A. Shirley; She was mentioned in the 1797 Augusta Co VA lawsuit deposition;

Augusta Co VA - May, 1799 Court. John Canote vs. Peter Shally.--Mary Shally, only daughter of Peter Shally, deposes, that about a year ago, her brother Christian, who had some time before been married to a daughter of John Canote, Sr., sister to plaintiff. 24th November, 1797. Mary Shally (Shirley) and Henry Harmon are about to remove, and also Sally Argenbright, November 17, 1797. 4th September, 1797, Christian Shally is about to remove to Kentucky.

   


Home Page | Contact

copyright Shirley Association
All Rights Reserved